Navigating the Social Security Earnings Test: A Guide for Retirees
Hi there! I’m Elisabeth Dawson, a financial advisor with over 26 years of experience. I’ve helped countless clients navigate the complexities of retirement planning, and one common question we get is about the Social Security earnings test. It can be confusing, so let’s break it down.
Understanding the Social Security Earnings Test
Social Security is more than just a monthly check; for many, it’s a lifeline during retirement. On average, Social Security represents 30% of a retiree’s income. But, if you start collecting benefits before your Full Retirement Age (FRA), and decide to continue working, your benefits may be affected. In fact, how much you can work without reducing your benefits is subject to strict rules. This is where the Social Security earnings test comes into play.
What Is the Social Security Earnings Test?
The Social Security earnings test is a set of rules designed to limit how much you can earn while still receiving your full Social Security benefits if you start taking them before reaching your FRA. Depending on your birth year, FRA ranges between 66 and 67. If you earn more than the set limits, a portion of your benefits will be withheld. But don’t worry—they’re not lost forever. I’ll explain more about that in a moment.
How the Earnings Test Works
The Social Security Administration (SSA) sets annual earnings limits. If your earnings exceed these limits, part of your Social Security benefits will be temporarily withheld.
Before Full Retirement Age (FRA)
If you’re under your FRA for the entire year, the SSA will deduct $1 from your benefits for every $2 you earn over the annual limit. For example, in 2024, this limit is $22,320. So, if you earn $25,000, you’ll be $2,680 over the limit. As a result, your benefits will be reduced by $1,340 ($2,680 divided by 2).
The Year You Reach Full Retirement Age
Now, things get a bit more lenient in the year you reach your FRA. The SSA deducts only $1 for every $3 you earn above a higher limit—$59,520 in 2024, to be exact. And here’s some good news: once you hit your FRA, there are no earnings limits! You can work as much as you like without affecting your benefits.
Why Does the Earnings Test Exist?
You might wonder why this test exists in the first place. The primary goal of the earnings test is to encourage people to stay in the workforce longer by reducing benefits for those who claim Social Security early while continuing to work. By delaying benefits, you can receive a higher monthly amount when you finally start collecting, which might be more advantageous in the long run.
Impact on Your Social Security Benefits
I often reassure my clients that any benefits withheld due to the earnings test aren’t lost forever. Once you reach your FRA, the SSA recalculates your benefit amount, factoring in the months when your benefits were withheld. This recalculation can lead to a higher monthly benefit for the rest of your life.
A Practical Example
To make this clearer, let’s walk through an example. Imagine you start receiving Social Security at age 62, with a monthly benefit of $1,500. You decide to keep working, earning $30,000 a year. Since the 2024 earnings limit is $22,320, you exceed the limit by $7,680. Consequently, your benefits will be reduced by $3,840 ($7,680 divided by 2).
Here’s the math: Your annual Social Security benefits would be $18,000 ($1,500 multiplied by 12). After the reduction, you’d receive $14,160 in benefits for that year. When you reach your FRA, the SSA will adjust your benefit amount, potentially increasing your monthly benefit for the future.
Strategies for Managing Earnings and Maximizing Benefits
Over the years, we’ve helped many clients successfully navigate the earnings test. It’s important to understand that what’s right for one person’s situation may not be the best choice for you. That’s why is crucial to run your own numbers or seek the personalized advice of a knowledgeable financial advisor such as a member of our Copia team.
Here are some strategies that can help you manage your earnings and get the most out of your Social Security benefits.
Delay Collecting Benefits
One of the most effective strategies to avoid the earnings test is to delay collecting your Social Security benefits until you reach your FRA or later. This way, you can continue working without worrying about a reduction in benefits. Plus, by delaying benefits, your monthly payout increases by about 8% for each year you wait beyond your FRA until age 70.
Adjust Your Work Schedule
If delaying benefits isn’t an option and you need to start collecting early, consider adjusting your work schedule. By reducing your hours, you might be able to keep your earnings below the annual limit, thus avoiding a reduction in benefits while still supplementing your income.
Plan for the Year You Reach FRA
When you’re close to reaching your FRA, it’s time to start thinking strategically. The earnings test is more lenient in the year you reach your FRA, so it might make sense to delay certain work projects or additional income until after you reach FRA. This approach can help maximize your benefits while allowing you to earn more without penalties.
Consider the Timing of Your Benefits
Timing is everything when it comes to Social Security. The decision of when to start collecting can significantly impact your overall retirement income. In fact, retirees will collectively lose about $3.4 trillion, or an average of $110,000 per household, in income due to claiming Social Security at a financially sub-optimal time. If you start early, be aware of the earnings test and its potential effects. On the other hand, if you can afford to delay, doing so might increase your lifetime benefits and help you avoid the earnings test altogether.
Work Part-Time or Seasonally
Another strategy could be transitioning to part-time or seasonal work during the years leading up to your FRA. This allows you to continue earning an income while keeping your earnings below the threshold, minimizing any reduction in benefits. Then, once you reach FRA, you can return to full-time work without worrying about the earnings test.
Understanding the Long-Term Impact
It’s essential to consider the long-term impact of the earnings test on your retirement plan. While having your benefits reduced temporarily can be frustrating, remember that this reduction isn’t permanent. The SSA recalculates your benefits at FRA, potentially leading to a higher monthly payout for the rest of your life.
When deciding when to start collecting Social Security, you should also consider your individual financial situation, life expectancy, and retirement goals. For some, the immediate need for income may outweigh the benefits of delaying Social Security. For others, waiting might be the better option.Remember, the Social Security earnings test is an important factor for anyone planning to retire and collect benefits before reaching full retirement age. By understanding how the test works and its impact on your benefits, you can make informed decisions about your retirement income both now and into the future. Considering strategies like delaying benefits, adjusting your work schedule, and planning for the year you reach FRA, can help you effectively manage your earnings and maximize your Social Security benefits.
Consulting with a Financial Advisor
Deciding when to claim Social Security can have a lasting impact on your retirement picture so you want to be strategic. Ultimately, careful planning and consulting with an experienced financial advisor can help you navigate the complexities of these decisions to ensure a secure, comfortable retirement. We can guide you through the rules, help you understand how the earnings test might affect your benefits, outline your various options, and work with you to develop a strategy that aligns with your retirement goals.
We’re here to help you navigate the complexities of the Social Security system and ensure a secure, comfortable retirement. Feel free to reach out if you have any questions or need further guidance.
Schedule your complimentary consultation here or contact our team at Copia Wealth Management and Insurance Services by calling (619) 640-2622.
We are a leading financial advisor in San Diego specializing in tailored retirement planning.
